I know what you are thinking..."What the hell does a goy that grew up in the south know from egg creams?"
I can remember a film during the Kukla Fran and Ollie Show when I was a kid. It was about two immigrant Jewish boys in Brooklyn. The fat one was obsessed with egg creams. One day, all the kids on the block collected money to see how many egg creams this little boy could drink in one afternoon at the drug store in their neighborhood. I can still remember the close ups of the fat kid's face as he was downing the last few egg creams...visibly getting sicker and sicker. He was obviously about to hurl egg cream all the way down his block in Depression era Brooklyn.
From then on, I was curious about egg creams. What was an Egg Cream? I forgot about them until a few years later, when Barbra Streisand went for egg creams with her rich boyfriend in a scene from Funny Girl. I really had to know then. If Barbra liked Fanny Brice enough to play her in a movie, I liked her too. And...if Fanny Brice liked egg creams, I liked them too.
_____________________________________________________________________
The first few times I finally got to New York, all my friends wanted to do was to hit the clubs like CBGB, Max's, and The Mudd Club that we were reading about in music magazines. I loved doing that too, but I also wanted to score an egg cream to see what the fuss was all about.
The first thing that I learned was...there are no eggs and no cream in an egg cream. hmmm
_____________________________________________________________________
I still always make it a point to have one in a different place every time I go up now. Last August, we went to Sammy's Steak House on the Lower East Side, where they let you make your own. They brought the U Bet Syrup, a carton of whole milk, and a seltzer bottle to the table. They made the first one for us clueless gentiles at the table...and then they left all the stuff and let us make as many as we wanted.
(The garlic smeared skirt steaks at Sammy's are to freakin' DIE for. They are huge. They are about 2 inches longer than the plate on both sides. The crowd at Sammy's is a wild mix of old Russians and Jews, families coming back into the old neighborhood for the night, kids from NYU, etc etc. They make the MOST INCREDIBLE chopped liver right at your table. There is a guy playing a Hammond organ and singing cheeeeeeesy songs ala "Tony Orlando minus Dawn" for entertainment. When you sit down, they don't even ask what you want to drink...they immediately bring chilled Russian vodka to the table with the water. There is even a jar of schmaltz at every table.)
A night at Sammy's Steakhouse is a trip! It's not on any tourist maps. You would pass by the basement entrance and never notice it. Once you get in, you feel like you have been transported back to a friendly slice of the old neighborhood that hasn't changed for 60 years. We hung out for hours and had a BLAST!
The matchbook that I saved gives the pertinent info:
Famous Sammy's Roumanian Steakhouse
157 Chrystie Street
NYC 10002
_____________________________________________________________________
What was I talking about?....oh yeah....Egg Creams....
You know how random and OCD my grocery shopping is, right? I'm sure I was supposed to be in Krogers for bread or garbage bags or toilet paper or some nonsense like that, but instead I bought a bottle of Fox's U Bet and some seltzer water Friday night and have been practicing the art of the egg cream.

The chocolate syrup HAS to be Fox's U Bet for an authentic Egg Cream.

You don't have to, but I stir the milk and the U Bet a little before I pour in the seltzer.
Pour the seltzer water down a long spoon or along the side of the glass so you dont get too much foam too early. Then stir vigorously around the bottom until you get a foam head that rises just to the top of the glass.
The ideal Egg Cream has a dark brown bottom, light chocolate middle, and about an inch and a half of beautiful white foam.
The fellow in the next photo has just achieved the perfect egg cream. No wonder he looks so deleriously happy. Just look at that egg cream!

T